Starting a Business With a Friend Is Exciting. And Then Life Happens.
In 1978, childhood friends Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield took a $5 correspondence course in ice cream making and opened their first scoop shop in a renovated Vermont gas station. Together, they built Ben & Jerry’s into a household name (who doesn’t love some The Tonight Dough or Netflix & Chill’d?), navigating decades of growth while keeping their friendship intact right through their eventual sale of the company in 2000. Not a bad return on their $5 investment!
It’s the ultimate business partnership dream.
But for every Ben and Jerry, there’s also a Zuckerberg and Saverin.
Mark Zuckerberg and Eduardo Saverin started out as college roommates co-founding Facebook in a Harvard dorm room. As the company exploded, however, disagreements over business direction and control turned toxic. Saverin’s shares were severely diluted, sparking bitter, high-profile lawsuits and a permanent fallout with the drama famously immortalized in the movie The Social Network. Needless to say, their friendship disappeared faster than the days when our feeds were full of real friends instead of ads and petty neighborhood disputes.
When you launch a business with a friend, you’re focused on the excitement of building something great together, not on courtroom battles. You’re picking a company logo and dreaming of your favorite coffee machine, not thinking about a future dissolution. But life happens. People’s goals shift, finances change, or someone simply decides they’re ready for new scenery. Without a clear game plan, a partner wanting out can quickly turn a thriving business—and what you thought was a lifelong friendship—into a legal headache.
That’s where business planning and a buy-sell agreement can come in.
What Exactly Is a Buy-Sell Agreement?
Think of a buy-sell agreement as a "prenup" for your business. It’s a legally binding contract between co-owners that spells out exactly what happens if one partner decides to leave, retires, becomes disabled, or passes away. Think of it as a contingency plan for your partnership.
Instead of scrambling to negotiate under stress or guessing what a departing partner's share is worth, the rules are already decided while everyone is still on the same page. Like a prenup can prevent some of the messiness of a divorce and allow for a more peaceful dissolution, a buy-sell agreement can help you turn into Ben and Jerry rather than Mark and Eduardo.
How It Saves Both Your Business and Your Friendship
Money and ambiguity are two of the fastest ways to ruin a friendship. A solid buy-sell agreement removes the guesswork by answering three major questions upfront:
● Who can buy the departing partner’s shares? Usually, the agreement gives the remaining partner or the company itself the "right of first refusal." That means you won't suddenly find yourself co-owning a business with your friend’s spouse, a random investor, or someone you don't know.
● How much is the business worth? Valuing a small business from scratch during a breakup is a recipe for resentment. Your agreement sets a clear, pre-approved valuation formula so everyone knows the buyout price is fair.
● How will the buyout get paid? Few small businesses have piles of cash sitting around for an instant lump-sum buyout. Your agreement can outline manageable payment terms, like an installment plan or life insurance funding, so buying out your partner doesn’t bankrupt the company.
Why It Matters Here in Minnesota
If you run an LLC, corporation, or partnership in Minnesota without a buy-sell agreement, state law decides what happens when someone leaves, and those default rules often don’t fit with small businesses and relational goals. Like a living trust gives you the final say regarding your assets and beneficiaries, a buy-sell lets you determine the future of your business. Without your own plan in place under Minnesota statutes, a disagreement can spiral into a court-ordered buyout, and then a judge—not you—decides what your business is worth. Even better, while Minnesota largely banned employee non-competes, state law (Minn. Stat. § 181.988) still allows reasonable non-compete terms when an owner sells their share of a business. That means your agreement can protect your client list if your partner moves on.
Set the Ground Rules While Things Are Good
Putting a buy-sell agreement in place isn't a sign that you don't trust your business partner; instead, it’s proof that you value the relationship enough to protect it. Having these honest conversations early keeps expectations clear and lets you both focus on growing your business without unnecessary worries for the future.
Are you thinking about a partnership? Or are you realizing you haven’t properly laid the groundwork for your growing business? Reach out to Miroslavich Law today. We’ll help you put together a straightforward plan tailored to your business, so you can protect both your bottom line and your friendship. Maybe we can even discuss your future over a pint of Ben and Jerry’s!